Clicky Gone: A Beginner’s Guide to Silencing Mechanical Switch ClicksMechanical keyboards are beloved for their tactile feedback and satisfying sounds, but not everyone wants the loud “clicky” profile that some switches produce. Whether you share a workspace, stream, or just prefer a quieter typing experience, this guide walks you through practical, beginner-friendly methods to reduce or eliminate switch clicks while keeping most of the feel you enjoy.
Why Clicks Happen
Mechanical switch clickiness comes from their design:
- Clicky switches (e.g., Cherry MX Blue, Kailh Box White) include a dedicated mechanism that produces an audible click at actuation.
- Tactile switches provide a bump without an extra click mechanism.
- Linear switches are smooth and generally quieter.
Click noise is generated by:
- Internal switch mechanics (metal leaf, click bar, or slider shape).
- Keycap resonance and material.
- Keyboard plate and case amplifying vibrations.
- Stabilizers producing rattle on larger keys.
Quick changes (no soldering, beginner-friendly)
- Replace keycaps
- Swap ABS keycaps for PBT: PBT often reduces hollow resonance and sounds less sharp.
- Use thicker keycaps if available; they damp vibrations.
- Switch to rubber O-rings or landing pads
- Install O-rings on keycap stems to soften bottom-out impact and reduce high-frequency clack.
- Choose O-ring thickness (0.4–0.6 mm common) based on how much travel reduction you accept.
- Apply switch films (if your switches are hot-swappable)
- Films sit between the top and bottom halves of a switch to reduce wobble and micro-resonance, which cuts thin, high-pitched clicks.
- No soldering required for hot-swappable sockets.
- Change typing style
- Type lighter and avoid hard bottoming out; it noticeably reduces volume.
Intermediate steps (some disassembly, low risk)
- Lubricate switches (top and/or stem)
- Lubing moving parts reduces friction and the crispness of clicks. For clicky switches, lubing can soften but not entirely remove the engineered click.
- Recommended lubes:
- Krytox 205g0 for linear and tactile switches (stem/rail).
- Thin dielectric greases for springs and stabilizers.
- Use a small brush and apply sparingly; over-lubing can cause sluggish feel.
- Mod stabilizers
- Clip and lube stabilizers to remove rattle on spacebar, Enter, Shift, and Backspace.
- Common approach: disassemble stabilizers, clip the legs on PCB-style stab housings if needed, apply thin grease to housing and stabilizer wire, reassemble.
- Install foam or damping material
- Add foam between PCB and case, or under the plate, to absorb reverberations.
- Materials: neoprene, EVA foam, shelf liner, or specialized keyboard foam kits.
- Also add a thin strip of foam under the top frame to eliminate hollow sound.
Advanced options (more invasive)
- Replace switches with quieter types
- Swap clicky switches for tactile (e.g., Holy Panda, Zealios V2) or linear (e.g., Gateron Ink, Cherry Red) switches. For the quietest result, consider silent linear switches (e.g., Cherry MX Silent Red, Gateron Silent Black).
- If you want to preserve tactile feedback but lose the click, tactile non-clicky switches are the best compromise.
- Desolder and swap switches (if not hot-swappable)
- Requires a soldering iron, desoldering pump/braid, and basic soldering skills.
- Replace with desired quieter switches or silent variants.
- Modify switches to remove click mechanism
- For some clicky switches, physically altering the internal click mechanism (e.g., removing click bar) can silence them — not recommended for beginners as it permanently alters the switch and can damage it.
Choosing the right approach
- Want reversible, low-risk changes? Start with keycaps, O-rings, switch films, and foam.
- Want more silence while maintaining feel? Lubing, stabilizer mods, and switching to tactile or silent linear switches are effective.
- Want minimal investment and no tools? Change typing style and add O-rings.
Comparison table
| Action | Skill level | Reversibility | Effect on sound | Effect on feel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keycap swap (ABS→PBT, thicker) | Beginner | High | Moderate reduction | Slight change (duller sound) |
| O-rings | Beginner | High | Reduces bottom-out thock | Shortens travel slightly |
| Switch films | Beginner–Intermediate | High (if hot-swap) | Reduces thin clicks | Minimal |
| Lubing switches | Intermediate | High (can revert) | Reduces scratchy/clicky sounds | Smoother feel |
| Stabilizer mods | Intermediate | High | Eliminates rattle | Cleaner feel |
| Foam/damping | Beginner–Intermediate | High | Reduces resonance | Minimal |
| Replace switches | Intermediate–Advanced | High (if swapped back) | Major reduction | Depends on new switches |
| Desolder + swap | Advanced | High (requires skill) | Major reduction | Depends on new switches |
| Modify click mechanism | Advanced | Low (permanent) | Removes click | May harm switch |
Tools and materials checklist
- Keycap puller
- Switch puller (for hot-swap boards)
- O-rings or landing pads (various thickness)
- Switch films (if compatible)
- Lubricant (Krytox 205g0, Tribosys 3204) and fine brush
- Foam sheets (EVA/neoprene) or pre-cut kits
- Soldering iron and desoldering tools (for non-hot-swap)
- Small flathead screwdriver / tweezers for stabilizer work
Step-by-step example: Quieting a hot-swappable board (practical workflow)
- Remove keycaps and install PBT/thicker keycaps.
- Add O-rings to keycap stems you find loud.
- Insert switch films into each switch top if available.
- Lubricate switch stems lightly (optional) and reassemble.
- Replace noisy stabilizers: clip, lube, and reassemble.
- Place foam between PCB and case, then reassemble keyboard and test.
- If still too loud, swap in silent linear or tactile switches.
Troubleshooting common issues
- Keyboard feels mushy after lubing: likely over-lubed—clean excess and re-lube sparingly.
- Keys still rattle: stabilizers likely need further attention (re-lube, re-seat, or replace).
- Sound improved but not enough: consider replacing switches with silent variants.
Final recommendations
- Start with reversible, low-cost mods (keycaps, O-rings, films, foam). They often yield the biggest perceived improvement per effort.
- If you value tactile feedback but want quiet: choose tactile, non-clicky switches or silent tactile variants rather than modifying clicky switches.
- Take your time and test one change at a time so you know what produced the improvement.
If you want, tell me your keyboard model and whether it’s hot-swappable — I’ll give a tailored step-by-step plan and specific parts to buy.
Leave a Reply